Offshore Trusts 6 min read

Offshore Succession Planning: Passing a Cross-Border Estate

An estate held in one country, under one legal system, with a valid local will, is administered through one process. Add a holiday apartment in a second country, a brokerage account in a third and a company in a fourth, and the position changes completely.

An estate held in one country, under one legal system, with a valid local will, is administered through one process. Add a holiday apartment in a second country, a brokerage account in a third and a company in a fourth, and the position changes completely.

Each jurisdiction applies its own rules to the assets sitting within it. That can mean several separate court processes, running in sequence rather than parallel, in different languages, with different documentary requirements and no single person able to act across all of them. Meanwhile the family cannot access the assets.

What goes wrong

Multiple probates

Most jurisdictions require a local grant before assets situated there can be transferred. A grant obtained in one country is not automatically effective in another; it usually has to be resealed or a fresh application made, often requiring documents the first court has retained. Each process has its own timetable. Two years to complete a modest cross-border estate is unremarkable, and the cost is rarely proportionate to the value.

Forced heirship

Civil law jurisdictions across continental Europe, Latin America, the Middle East and elsewhere reserve a fixed portion of an estate for specified heirs – typically children, often a surviving spouse. That reserved portion is not discretionary. A will purporting to leave the estate elsewhere is reduced to the extent it trespasses on it.

This catches people who assume testamentary freedom is universal. It is not; it is a common law characteristic. A blended family, an intention to favour one child who has worked in the family business, a bequest to a partner rather than a spouse – each of these can be overridden entirely.

Within the EU, the Succession Regulation allows a person to elect the law of their nationality to govern succession, which can displace the forced heirship rules of their country of residence. The election has to be made properly and in advance, and it does not bind every jurisdiction where assets might sit.

Situs rules and conflicting wills

Which country’s law applies to which asset is determined by conflict of laws rules that differ by jurisdiction. Immovable property is commonly governed by the law where it is located, movable property by the law of the deceased’s domicile – but the definition of domicile is itself jurisdiction-specific.

The resulting accident is familiar: separate wills prepared in each country by local lawyers, each containing a standard revocation clause, the last one signed inadvertently revoking all the others. The estate then passes partly under one document and partly on intestacy.

Inheritance and estate taxes

Several jurisdictions may claim taxing rights over the same assets – by reference to the deceased’s residence or domicile, the heir’s residence, or the location of the asset. Estate tax treaties exist but are far less common than income tax treaties, so double taxation is a real possibility rather than a theoretical one.

What structures change

The common feature of the tools below is continuity of legal ownership. If legal title does not change on death, the asset is not part of an estate requiring a grant.

Trusts

Assets settled into a trust are owned by the trustee. The settlor’s death does not change that, so there is no transfer requiring probate and no asset in the personal estate for a local court to administer. Succession is governed by the trust deed, which operates continuously and privately.

A trust also provides something a will cannot: control over timing and conditions. Distributions can be staged by age or circumstance, a protector can hold oversight powers, and provision can be made for beneficiaries who are minors, vulnerable, or resident in jurisdictions where an outright inheritance would create problems.

The forced heirship interaction needs care. Several trust jurisdictions have firewall legislation providing that questions of validity are governed by local law and that foreign forced heirship claims are not recognised. Whether that holds in practice depends on where enforcement is attempted and what assets remain in the heirship jurisdiction. Our offshore trusts pages cover how different jurisdictions treat these questions.

Foundations

A foundation is a self-owning legal person with no shareholders, established for a purpose and administered by a council under a charter. It achieves a similar separation of ownership from the founder, through a civil law concept rather than a common law one.

For families from civil law backgrounds, that familiarity matters. A council structure is intuitive where a trustee holding legal title for beneficiaries is not, and advisers, banks and courts in those countries are more comfortable with it. Our offshore foundations pages set out how a foundation is constituted and administered, and the Cook Islands foundation page covers the jurisdiction most often used for this.

Holding companies

Interposing a company between the family and directly held foreign assets converts several asset classes in several countries into one asset: shares in a single company. Those shares then have one situs, governed by one set of rules, and can themselves be held by a trust or foundation.

This is particularly effective for real estate portfolios spread across jurisdictions, where direct ownership would otherwise require a separate process in each. Our offshore companies pages cover the jurisdictions commonly used.

Getting the documents to agree

Structures do not replace wills; they work alongside them. The two have to be drafted as one plan.

  • Scope each will explicitly. A will dealing with assets in one country should say so, and its revocation clause should be limited to prior wills dealing with those assets.
  • Keep one adviser holding the whole picture. Local counsel in each jurisdiction is necessary; somebody also has to read all the documents together.
  • Write the letter of wishes properly. It guides the trustee’s discretion and is where the reasoning belongs – particularly where beneficiaries are treated differently and the reasons would otherwise be guessed at.
  • Name successors. Successor protectors, successor council members, and a mechanism for replacing a trustee. Structures outlive the people who set them up.
  • Review on every change. A move, a marriage, a divorce, a birth, a new asset in a new country. Each can alter which rules apply.

Reporting has not gone away

None of this is private from tax authorities. Trusts and foundations are reportable under the Common Reporting Standard, settlors and beneficiaries have their own reporting obligations in their countries of residence, and distributions are generally taxable events for recipients.

The objective of a properly built succession structure is administrative certainty and continuity – not concealment. Structures presented as a way to place assets beyond the knowledge of tax authorities are describing something else.

Where to go next

The useful starting point is a list: what is owned, in which country, in whose name, and who is intended to receive it. The conflicts are usually visible as soon as that list exists, and they are far cheaper to resolve during life than afterwards.

Get in touch and we will connect you with trustees, foundation administrators and counsel in the relevant jurisdictions, and coordinate the plan across them.

Founder & Business Development Director

Co-founder of Wealth Web. Connor connects high-net-worth individuals with offshore trust, company, and banking structures across 20+ jurisdictions including the Cook Islands and Nevis.

Discuss your structuring goals.

A confidential, no-obligation consultation with a senior member of our team.